Dark Arts

June 14, 2012

On June 1, the New York Times reported that Obama has secretly ordered sophisticated attacks on the computer systems that run Iran’s main nuclear enrichment facilities. The US may not be alone in detonating cyberweapons—China, Israel, and Russia are also suspects—but its participation in the black arts robs the US of its ability to outlaw such warfare.

In an earlier attack, a worm called Stuxnet, developed by the US and Israel, was unleashed on the Natanz plant. It temporarily took out nearly 1,000 of the 5,000 centrifuges Iran had been using to purify uranium.  According to the New York Times report, President Obama had “secretly ordered increasingly sophisticated attacks on the computer systems that run Iran’s main nuclear enrichment facilities, significantly expanding America’s first sustained use of cyberweapons.”

For the US, employing cyberweapons is an attractive alternative to military strikes against Iran’s nuclear facilities. According to some experts, the Stuxnet worm set back Iran’s enrichment program by eighteen months to two years, although it should be noted that other experts outside the government are more skeptical. Currently, Iran has produced enough material for roughly five or more weapons.  At best, the initiation of cyberattacks by the US has enjoyed limited tactical benefits, but has set a dangerous precedent.

A year ago, it looked like the Obama administration was taking the high ground when it unveiled its “International Strategy for Cyberspace.”  The document said, among other things, that “aggressive acts in cyberspace” may be viewed by America as acts of war. “When warranted, the United States will respond to hostile acts in cyberspace as we would any other threat to our country,” which may mean the use of “military force.” The US “has no intention of sitting quietly while corporate and governmental computer systems are attacked with impunity.” The report goes on to take the moral high ground. “The digital world is no longer a lawless frontier … It is a place where the norms of responsible, just and peaceful conduct among states and peoples have begun to take hold.” Cyberspace must be “built on norms of responsible behavior.”

Having now engaged in a first strike, the US, by its own statements, is engaged in a preemptive war. Remember how much trouble the US got into the last time it engaged in such a war? Have they learned nothing from Iraq?  How might the US respond if Iran engaged some clever 14-year-old computer wiz to unleash a computer worm that attacks its electricity grid or other vital infrastructures?

The cyberattack on Iran comes under the category of “black ops,” dark arts that the US uses to hide its more unsavory activities. Black ops missions are built around “plausible deniability,” so responsibility cannot sheet home to the US. In the past, black operations have included such things as assassinations, economic sabotages, extortions, kidnappings, supporting insurgents and terrorists, and, more recently, through extraordinary rendition, tortures. The best estimate I can find for the size of the US black ops budget is $30 billion, although this figure consists of secret weapon programs, which are usually costly. And so, for decades, the US has preached to the world on the need for peace, democracy, liberty, and the rule-of-law, while employing “black ops” that undermine those very principles.

Iran is no stranger to US black ops. In 1953, the CIA engineered the overthrow of the democratically elected government of Iran led by Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh, who had been planning to nationalize his country’s petroleum industry. Little wonder that Iran has little appetite for negotiating with the US on its nuclear program, as history has shown that the US cannot be trusted.

Hypocrisy isn’t exactly a new thing in the affairs of nations. But, in this case, the US has put an end to the possibility of any enforceable international treaty to outlaw cyberwarfare.

5 Comments for this entry

  • Melanie says:

    To be fair, I don’t think anyone learned ANYTHING from Iraq. More’s the pity. So what make’s you think the US is any less adverse to another per-emptory war?

  • QT says:

    “Plausible deniability” is just code for “lie to the general public”.

  • Black Knight says:

    Whoa, whoa. Hypocrisy in the government?? Now that’s just absurd!

  • Ian Orchard says:

    And your point being, what exactly? All nations have indulged in one form or another of “black ops”. That has been the case since the Maccabees.

    • Harry says:

      Ian, you’re quite right. The difference is that globalization promises a new order in which conflicts are resolved through the rule of law. Publicly, he US has supported this policy, but privately its ‘black ops’ have sent out the opposite message.

Leave a Reply


Even more troubling, nearly sixteen million Americans must now travel at least thirty minutes or prada sunglasses for women more to reach a trauma center. Over the weekend prada sunglasses for women a new feature of Hulu was added - and then Cartier Sunglasses Men taken away. It is in light of this recently begun and still on-going exposure of the habitual and commonplace pederasty of priests that I find the Catholic Republican candidate for the Presidency's remarks about freedom of religion to be quite ingenuous. prada sunglasses for women Just recently I was told they finally found a prada sunglasses for women few bones after prada sunglasses for women many years of being buried in the sand. Although the fish were biting, I threw the boys in the car and raced down the canyon.

At some point, the crowd became restless and then they stormed forward, breaking down doors, tearing up papers and knocking over furniture. Cartier Sunglasses Men In addition to Assad stepping down and the observer mission continuing, the Arab League plan has called for the removal of heavy Cartier glasses weaponry out of the cities of Syria, including the capital, Damascus, an end on attacks on protesters, especially peaceful, unarmed protesters. During the observer's mission, nearly one thousand people were killed, including louis vuitton sunglasses women a large number of women